Keeper Selections
Below are the keeper selections for the 2023 Offseason, going into the 2023-24 season. Reminder that players can only be kept by the same manager for 2 consecutive seasons (for a total of 3 consecutive seasons if originally drafted by that manager).
* = drafted by current manager
** = drafted by another manager and traded to current manager
| Manager Name | Keeper Names | Keeper Forfeiture | Seasons Kept |
| Adam Zaloum |
Adam Fox Nikita Kucherov |
4th 4th |
2* (initial keep was done by another manager) 2** |
| Paul Brandao |
Jesper Bratt Evander Kane |
14th 15th |
|
| Kyle Froehner |
Brad Marchand Trevor Zegras |
4th 13th |
|
| Geordan Vincent |
Jack Hughes Adrian Kempe |
6th 8th |
2** |
| Nicholas Everett |
Tage Thompson Josh Morrissey |
9th 13th |
|
| Chase Natale | N/A | N/A | |
| Kyle Speranza |
Brandon Hagel Travis Konecney |
12th 14th |
|
| Noah Natale |
Moritz Seider Tom WIlson |
14th 17th |
|
| Kevin Buteau |
Jordan Eberle Sergei Bobrobski |
14th 14th |
|
| Frank Bishel |
Kirill Kaprizov Tim Stutzle |
6th 9th |
2** 1 |
| Anthony Altilio |
Nico Hischier Erik Karlsson |
7th 10th |
0 0 |
| Ken Smithington |
Matt Boldy Andrei Kuzmenko |
9th 18th |
0 0 |