| Team | Player | 2020-21 Draft Position | 2020-21 Final Rank | Keeper? | Keeper Cost | Successively Kept?\*\* | Notes |
| Adam's Team Sux | Martin Necas (Car - C,RW) | Round 18, Pick 7 | 62 | Y | 13th\* | N | Manager did not have 16th round pick, next pick available forfeited |
| Adam's Team Sux | Robin Lehner (VGK - G) | Round 17, Pick 11 | 560 | Y | 14th\* | N | Manager did not have 14th round pick, next pick available forfeited (12th) |
| Bro's Before Aho's | Elias Lindholm (Cgy - C,RW) | Round 15, Pick 6 | 39 | Y | 13th | 3x | |
| Bro's Before Aho's | Vincent Trocheck (Car - C) | Round 16, Pick 4 | 41 | Y | 14th | N | |
| Bro's Before Aho's | Elias Pettersson (Van - C) IR | Round 11, Pick 6 | 385 | Y | 9th | 3x | |
| Comeback Kid 2022 | Trevor Zegras (Anh - C,LW) | Round 20, Pick 4 | 591 | Y | 17th\* | N | Manager did not have 18th round pick, next pick available forfeited |
| Comeback Kid 2022 | Kirby Dach (Chi - C) O | Round 17, Pick 10 | 629 | Y | 15th | N | |
| Comeback Kid 2022 | Cole Caufield (Mon - RW) | - | 701 | Y | 11th | N | |
| Dudeman | Jeff Petry (Mon - D) O | Round 16, Pick 2 | 32 | Y | 14th | 2x | |
| Dudeman | Pavel Buchnevich (StL - RW) | Round 12, Pick 2 | 49 | Y | 10th | N | |
| Faulk Me | Alex DeBrincat (Chi - LW,RW) | Round 6, Pick 1 | 7 | Y | 4th | N | |
| Faulk Me | Max Pacioretty (VGK - LW) | Round 9, Pick 8 | 22 | Y | 7th | 1x | |
| Faulk Me | Tyler Seguin (Dal - C,RW) O | Round 15, Pick 10 | 772 | Y | 13th | N | |
| Fleury's Sword | Kirill Kaprizov (Min - LW,RW) | Round 12, Pick 7 | 28 | Y | 10th | N | |
| Fleury's Sword | Nino Niederreiter (Car - LW,RW) | Round 18, Pick 6 | 109 | Y | 16th | N | |
| Fleury's Sword | Thatcher Demko (Van - G) | Round 15, Pick 11 | 205 | Y | 13th | N | |
| I Have Hughes Nutz | James van Riemsdyk (Phi - LW) | Round 17, Pick 1 | 72 | Y | 15th\* | N | |
| Mike's Team | Tyler Toffoli (Mon - LW,RW) O | Round 12, Pick 3 | 29 | Y | 10th | N | |
| Mike's Team | Adam Larsson (Sea - D) | - | 172 | Y | 11th | N | |
| NathansHotDogContest | Joe Pavelski (Dal - C,RW) | Round 16, Pick 13 | 18 | Y | 14th | N | |
| NathansHotDogContest | Ryan O'Reilly (StL - C) | Round 8, Pick 13 | 26 | Y | 6th | N | |
| NathansHotDogContest | Yanni Gourde (Sea - C,RW) O | Round 21, Pick 1 | 136 | Y | 19th | N | |
| Noah's Team Swallows | Semyon Varlamov (NYI - G) | Round 14, Pick 10 | 80 | Y | 12th | N | |
| Noah's Team Swallows | Josh Norris (Ott - C) | - | 94 | Y | 9th | N | Manager did not have 11th round pick, next pick available forfeited |
| Noah's Team Swallows | Nikita Kucherov (TB - RW) | - | 1144 | Y | 8th | N | Season-Long IR Rule applies, 3 rounds ahead of specified keeper value |
| Occasional Winners | Tyson Barrie (Edm - D) | Round 10, Pick 7 | 38 | Y | 8th | N | |
| Occasional Winners | Jakub Vrana (Det - LW) | Round 19, Pick 9 | 140 | Y | 17th | N | |
| Occasional Winners | Nico Hischier (NJ - C) | Round 14, Pick 6 | 528 | Y | 12th | N | |
| Puck Tails Pauly B | David Perron (StL - LW,RW) | Round 19, Pick 3 | 20 | Y | 17th | N | |
| Puck Tails Pauly B | Nikolaj Ehlers (Wpg - LW,RW) | Round 11, Pick 3 | 55 | Y | 9th | N | |
| Puck Tails Pauly B | Roope Hintz (Dal - C,LW) | Round 18, Pick 12 | 81 | Y | 16th | N | |
| return of the king | Drew Doughty (LA - D) | Round 11, Pick 14 | 78 | Y | 9th | N | |
| return of the king | Philipp Grubauer (Sea - G) | Round 14, Pick 7 | 134 | Y | 12th | N | |
| Your Moms PenaltyBox | Kyle Palmieri (NYI - LW,RW) NA | Round 9, Pick 4 | 241 | Y | 7th | N |
|